Don Martini's WHO WAS WHO AMONG THE SOUTHERN INDIANS (1998), p254 lists your guy as:
.
*********************
.
"Foreman, John Anthony - Cherokee, was born June 10, 1844, the son of Stephen Foreman. He served in the CSA and later as a major, Third Indian Home Guards, Union Army, during the Civil War (1). In 1880, he lived alone in Cooweescoowee District. Elected judge there in 1883. He was a resident of Roswell, New Mexico, in 1900. He died in January, 1919. Married Eliza Blythe and Nancy Amanda Smith. He was the father of Josephine Gertrude Foreman (2).

1) THE WAR OF THE REBELLION, v. 41, pt 4, 985.
2) Cherokee Dawes Card 5244; HISTORY OF ROGERS COUNTY, OKLAHOMA; sTARR, 363-366."
.
*********************
.
Martini's book lists four men named "John Foreman," two named "Johnson Foreman," and none named "Forman."
.
Patti, prochette@Juno.com
.