The Indian Territory in the Civil War Message Board

Capt McIntosh; Feb 27, 1859; Co D, 1st Cav

Please help find the primary source for the following statement:
.
*********
.
4. February 27-28, 1859. Caddo Creek, near Fort Arbuckle.
.
“A detachment from Company D of the 1st Cavalry, under the command of Capt. J. McIntosh, attack and killed seven Comanches on Caddo Creek.”
.
*********
.
I found this statement:

On page 95 of HISTORICAL ATLAS OF OKLAHOMA, 4th Edition, Norman OK, University of Oklahoma Press, (2006) 286pp by Charles Robert Boins and Danney Goble.
.
It's rather easy to find references to this Feb 1859 event, but I cannot find "Capt. J. McIntosh" associated with this Feb 1869 event. Below is what I have thus far about this event:
.
1859 Fort Arbuckle, I.T., Feb 27-28..
Lt-Col. W.H. Emory sent Lt. D.S. Stanley’s Company D of 53 men, 1st U.S. Cavalry, to pursue a thieving party of Comanches who had been committing depredations in the vicinity of the post including the W.L. Moncrief farm five miles from Fort Arbuckle.
“A detachment from Company D, under the command of Capt. James McIntosh, attacked and killed seven Comanches on Caddo Creek [now Graham, Carter Co OK].”
.
Graham, Carter County OK. ... Notice that Graham OK, our Oklahoma neighbor. That's why it is SO SO important that we find the source document for Goins' entry.
.

References besides Goins are:
.
pp131ff of ..Dennis Muncrief’s A HISTORY OF FT. ARBUCKLE, ITS PEOPLE AND TIMES, self-published 2004, Murray County OK (printed Bloomington IN), 274pp.

p54 of ..Wm. B. Justiss' FORT ARBUCKLE, OUTPOST IN INDIAN TERRITORY, 1850-1870, University of Arkansas 1976 Master’s Thesis, p54. that cited: ANNUAL REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF WAR, 1859, pp356-357.
.
The Google search term I used in finding this Feb 27-28, 1859 event was: >>emory stanley 1859 moncrief<<
.
McIntosh researchers are hereby on alert.
.
It would be nice if either Charles Robert Goins or Danney Goble would contact me. It is time that Southern Oklahoma is recognized as part of Oklahoma history.
.
Any suggestions would be appreciated and followed.
.
Patti, prochette@Juno.com
.

Messages In This Thread

Capt McIntosh; Feb 27, 1859; Co D, 1st Cav
Re: Capt McIntosh; Feb 27, 1859; Co D, 1st Cav
Re: Capt McIntosh; Feb 27, 1859; Co D, 1st Cav
Re: Capt McIntosh; Feb 27, 1859; Co D, 1st Cav
Battle of Wichita Village, Rush Springs OK
Re: Battle of Wichita Village, Rush Springs OK
Battle of Wichita Village, Rush Springs OK
Re: Moncrief
Chris Columbus Colbert, 1st Choctaw-Chickasaw Vols
Re: Chris Columbus Colbert, 1st Choctaw-Chickasaw