Mike Glen Thompson,
.
I know that "Capt. James McIntosh" was at Fort Arbuckle in Feb 1859 because he is listed in Lt. David S. Stanley's Co D, 1st U.S. Cavalry from Oct 12, 1858 until after Feb 1859 on pp122, 243, 131 in Dennis Muncrief's HISTORY OF FT. ARBUCKLE. Dennis references "Feb 1859 post returns." ..Dennis may have seen the original post returns, because I interviewed a gent who said as a kid, he and the friend he was visiting in he Ft. Arbuckle area, would look at the original Ft. Arbuckle post returns.
.
Dennis Muncrief’s A HISTORY OF FT. ARBUCKLE, ITS PEOPLE AND TIMES, self-published 2004, Murray County OK (printed Bloomington IN), 274pp.
.
.
Still looking for the C.R. Goins resourse in:
.
*******
4. February 27-28, 1859. Caddo Creek, near Fort Arbuckle.
.
“A detachment from Company D of the 1st Cavalry, under the command of Capt. J. McIntosh, attack and killed seven Comanches on Caddo Creek.”

On page 95 of HISTORICAL ATLAS OF OKLAHOMA, 4th Edition, Norman OK, University of Oklahoma Press, (2006) 286pp by Charles Robert Goins and Danney Goble.
.
********
.
Thank you for the help.
.
Patti, prochette@Juno.com
.