Hi Sheila, from the info I've found, the line you've shown here is a 'rabbit'. I found where Emma filed papers and Patrick is listed as Patrick "C" rather than Patrick L in all of his military papers that include his middle initial. If you need copies of them, I have them. Also, I found that he died as a POW in Camp Butler, Sangamon Co., IL and is buried there in the military cemetery. I also found out more info on him this weekend at the family reunion. I just have not found anything to point out which Patrick L. McCawley in Ireland that he is. Hopefully, I find out more on that soon. Will share more with you on facebook. deb