The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?

Dennis,

After a couple of days of thinking about this question, I am struck about something. Why are we worried about "legality"?

I mean doesn't the Federal example of disregarding the Constitution during the War Between the States demonstrate the principal that "Might makes Right".

If that is the case then there is no need to question the legality of any matter because mob rule (even a Federal Army) superceeds the Law.

Messages In This Thread

Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Texas vs White. *NM*
Re: Texas vs White.
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Texas vs. White
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Re: Secession legality - before and after the CW?
Historian, Lawyer, Ohioian
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioian
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioian
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioian
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan
Re: Historian, Lawyer, Ohioan