The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: I would like to
In Response To: Re: I would like to ()

Can a man actually be a traitor to a government which has been imposed on him, when he still recognizes the National government as HIS government?

Let's paint a scenario which is free from 150 years of emotional baggage.

In the American Southwest, several states will, in the near future, have a population in which Hispanics are the majority. Now, let us say that the Hispanic-dominated legislatures of those states cook up a list of grievances against the United States, decide that their rights are being trampled, vote to secede from the Union, issue a declaration of independence, and form their own country. They immediately raise an army and enforce conscription on all military-age males residing in their new country.

And, let's assume that the President and Congress of the United States determine that this new Hispanic nation is unconstitutional and order the U.S. Army, Marines, Navy and Air Force to engage and defeat the Hispanic army and reestablish law and order.

Now, suppose that many of the white residents, whose families have lived in the Southwest for generations, who do not endorse the actions of their State legislatures, and want to remain American citizens, leave their homes and join the U.S. Armed Forces and fight to restore what they consider to be the legitimate government.

Are those men traitors? Traitors to what? To their State, which they believe has been illegally taken over? To the Hispanic national government, which they feel was imposed upon them against their will?

Or are they patriots, risking their lives to fight for their government and flag?

Loaded words are like loaded guns. They should be used with great care and only in the appropriate context.

Messages In This Thread

I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Only 3,000 Mexican lived in Texas *NM*
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Not Americans?
Re: Not Americans?
Nice dodge...
Re: Nice dodge...
Re: Nice dodge...
Re: Nice dodge...
Lordy Miss Scarlett the Americans are coming!
Re: Lordy Miss Scarlett the Americans are coming!
Who the heck are we?
Re: Who the heck are we?
Re: Who the heck are we?
Re: Who the heck are we?
Re: Who the heck are we?
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Nationality and Governments...
Re: Nationality and Governments...
Re: Nationality and Governments...
Re: Nationality and Governments...
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to
Re: I would like to