The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Let's cut to the Chase
In Response To: Let's cut to the Chase ()

Ok, if that is your stance, then prove that secession was illegal prior to 1869, you can't because it wasn't. True Chase did not say it was "legal", he said it was not illegal under the Consitution. A mix of words but it means the same.

Like I said, I'm not going to try to prove to you different, I and David already have, now you prove your point, with book or "computer" source. But the date of any decision has to be prior to 1860.

These conversations are always the same someone like you comes out with the politicaly correctt version of the War and we bend over backwards trying to show you the truth. Well if you are so sure you are right show me that I am wrong. In a court of law the prosecution has to show cause that the defendant is guilty not vice versa.

So step up to the late and make your case. Lets see if you can prove S.P.Chase wrong. Oh yeah, in the book Rise and fall of the Confederate Government, a book I own in my library on the shelf, not computer, The same ruling/statement is written as what we have typed. Go buy the book you can read it yourself.

Messages In This Thread

A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Uh Huh...
Re: Uh Huh...
Re: Uh Huh...
Re: Uh Huh...
Re: Uh Huh...
Re: Uh Huh...
Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Jefferson Davis Pardon
Your Answer
Re: Absolutely no case...
Re: Absolutely no case...
Another reference...
Re: Another reference...
Your welcome... *NM*
Re: Absolutely no case...
Salmon P. Chase
Chase on Chase
Re: Chase on Chase
Re: Chase on Chase
Re: Chase on Chase
Look out....
Re: Look out....
Re: Chase on Chase
Let's cut to the Chase
Re: Let's cut to the Chase
Re: Uh Huh...
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought
Re: A Thought