The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: It almost didn't start
In Response To: Re: It almost didn't start ()

Opening lines of Richard III. Great play, and great play on words.

Chase, I never really considered Meade a great general in the same way that I never gave credit for the rebel victory at Saratoga to Gates, not Arnold.

Same with Hancock, Buford, Zook, Stannard and other great field commanders who were at the right place at the right time.

I think you have to give the Yanks credit for staying on the field, instead of riding around the periphery trying to get their names in the Northern papers and such.

When I think of Winfield Scott Hancock, I think of a Union general as good as any field commander ever put up by the South. As good a man as ol Bobby Lee.

If you ever read that book by Glenn Tucker, Hancock the Superb, the poor guy went broke entertaining digntitaries at the orders of the govt. Which is better than being killed on the field I guess.

Messages In This Thread

The Picketts Charge was almost stopped
almost?..I thought it was stopped *NM*
Only in the Northern version..LOL *NM*
LOL...I think Pickett might agree *NM*
Re: LOL...I think Pickett might agree
It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start
Re: It almost didn't start