The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Lincoln # 1
In Response To: Re: Lincoln # 1 ()

Mark,

I've searched everywhere and I can't find a list of these so-called "65 historians". The only one referenced in any of the articles is Edna Medford. Here is a link to her Howard university webpage, http://www.coas.howard.edu/history/faculty_Medford.html .

I find it interesting that Lincoln was No. 1 and this lady who is listed as a "survey adviser and participant" in other locations, is referred to as a "Lincoln Historian". Sounds like kind of a fixed deal to me.

To me it's just another attempt by a group of anonymous ideologs to promote "their" views as some credentialed and pervasive viewpoint. Hogwash!

Why don't we have 65 of our participants/historians do a poll of the best president and submit the results to a national publication? You think they'd print it?

Jim

Messages In This Thread

Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
I meant #1 & #3 *NM*
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
Re: Lincoln # 1
List of 65 Historians
James McPherson
Re: James McPherson
Re: James McPherson
Re: James McPherson
Re: James McPherson
Annelise Anderson
Re: Annelise Anderson
Walter Burns
John Milton Cooper
Robert Dallek
Thomas Fleming
Pauline Maier
Re: Pauline Maier
Re: Pauline Maier
Mary Stucky "Ole Miss"
Re: Pauline Maier
Re: Pauline Maier
Douglas Brinkley
Henry William Brands
Re: Selection Criteria
Re: Selection Criteria
Re: Selection Criteria
Re: Selection Criteria
Re: Selection Criteria