The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: The threat of secession
In Response To: Re: The threat of secession ()

"This straight forward speech about arming the slaves cost him the command of the Army of the Tennessee which he should have been commanding instead of Bragg. So I am really sure that Cleburne was following the lead of popular opinion when he suggested that the slave should be armed. Like a fish in a pickle dish he was following popular opinion."

I think you assume incorrectly (but it is a good discussion)...I don't think Davis questioned at all Cleburne's patriotism, but seemed aghast at the Cleburne proposal of arming slaves. Davis was prejudiced against giving high command to those who were not of the West Point upbringing militarily. (Forrest was not West Point, but was given an independent command, but not a whole army.) Also Cleburne was a signer of petitions against Bragg, something to not be forgiven by the spiteful Davis. Bragg said that “We must mark the men”, and “agitators must be watched” after he go kicked upstairs to the Davis cabinet. Read correspondence between the principle players in the Cleburne proposal, and it gets intense. (W.H.T. Walker got pretty emotional about the proposal, he didn’t like it!)
Authors of book about Cleburne seem to be of the opinion that Cleburne got passed by more from not having a West Point education.

Kevin Dally

Messages In This Thread

The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
True issues....
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: I am wrong....
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Well done!
Re: Well done!
Thanks, Doyle! *NM*
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession
Re: The threat of secession