The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville

The book reads like the script from the movie Andersonville. My question is for those who are experts with Andersonville, familiar with the movie, were the events in the movie true or where they taken from experiences of other soldiers at other camps?

Below is a sample.

[We field officers were quartered that night in a brick building near the entrance, where we passed an hour of horrors. We were attacked by what appeared to be an organized gang of desperadoes, made up of thieves, robbers, Yankee deserters, rebel deserters, and villains generally, maddened by hunger, or bent on plunder, who rejoiced in the euphonious appellation of Muggers! We had been warned against them by kindly disposed guards, and were not wholly unprepared. They attacked us with clubs, fists, and knives, but were repeatedly driven off, pitched headlong downstairs. '' Muggers I'']

[One captain, who had been a prisoner before and seemed glad to have been captured again, a bloated, overgrown, swaggering, filthy bully, of course a coward, formerly a keeper of a low groggery and said to have been commissioned for political reasons, was repeatedly heard to say in sneering tones in the hearing of rebel sentries, "Some of our officers have got escape on the brain," with other words to the like effect. Colonel Hartshorne finally stopped such traitorous language by saying with tremendous emphasis: "Captain D , I've heard a good deal of your attempts to discourage officers from escaping, and your loud talk about officers having 'escape on the brain.' Now, sir, I give you notice that if you're again guilty of anything of the sort, I'll—Break—Your Head—With—A Club!"]

It looks as if history was twisted or stolen for a good screen play, thats why I am asking. The movie "Gettysburg" and "Gods and Generals" tried to stick to events that really occured, as they happend, did the movie "Andersonville" get it right?

____________________________________
David Upton

Messages In This Thread

Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville
Re: Andersonville vs Salisbury/Danville