The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights

Ok, I'm sorry. Was half asleep when I asked all that. After the Recent Unpleasantness, a push was made to prevent states from having the power to leave the union. Leaving was something the Confederate States thought was a given right but the yayhoos in DC said it really wasn't. Other than the Bill of Rights and the Dec or Indy, do you know if there is anything written down, like in stone, or on record, that states any of the State Rights or the Sovereignty of the states? That the states have their own power has been assumed I guess but I've only seen it 'stated' in the document each used as an Article of Confederation. We know how well those floated. Even if those were kind of correct, they were blown right out of the water first off by the big guns.

I don't know where I came up with the 10th amend. I think I was thinking about the post I had just read and since we can't refer back to the post on this page I was rambling-----again. Sorry. Now, if ever there were another Taxation Without Representation moment, we're seeing it and since the Revolutionary War, I was trying to find what has changed to keep states from just saying "NO" to federal mandates. The Bill of Rights is very clear to most of us, but it seems to be very cloudy to others in an area next to Virginia. It took a lot of time, money and more important, lives, to give us these rights. They were not upheld though many a learned person believed they should be in the 1860's. Sooo, I'll withdraw my question til I can figure out how to reword it the right way. You known me, I'm tilting at imaginary windmills again. :)

Pam

Messages In This Thread

State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights
Re: State Sovereignty vs States Rights