The book certainly does that. For what it's worth, it was required reading in one of my graduate courses on Civil War. I'm always bothered by things that are incomplete, misleading or questionable. Guess that means I'm always bothered.

The mere mention of either "Killer Angels" or "Gettysburg" (the movie) once put an automatic frown on my face. It's been twenty years; I'm getting better about a neutral response.