The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Question
In Response To: Re: Question ()

Ok, I think I'm understanding that Stan. Lee was able to 'see' things at times others may not have thought of. He did some of that in Mexico from what I've read. It may have been an 'inspired' move had he chosen to do so. Lee was so very close to victory and it seems to me Gettysburg is where it began to fade away. I'm not sure what would have happened if there had been victory or how things would have played out and we will never know. I'd bet there were a few who wished "Stonewall" would show up. That's a lot of worry to put on one mans shoulders. Even though the end result was not as hoped, I can't think of anyone better to command the ANV.

I'm trying to understand some of the 'battlefield' terms and tactics better. That began when I wanted to know where my Florida GGGrand was when he was captured July2. The Park Service had a series of books on the different battlefield parks and the one I bought on Gettysburg has really helped me 'see' things when I read about an incident. I want to try to see it as they did. Not that it's anything like what they saw. After learning of my Georgia Grands being at Devil's Den, I got to looking at that and just wonder how they made it home alive. Maybe Gettysburg was one of the places they all should have avoided. I think Lee was really pushing because he knew they needed the supplies. Guess they didn't count on the fence at Emmittsburg Road being so strong or (after the cussion and discussion, I'm calling it the) Northen Army being on high ground first. Then the Northen Troops decided to rebound on the hill (thank ol "Don't call me Lawrence" for that one) and the Alabama boys drew the short straw on that dance. Just one bad series of incidents that possibly changed the course of the entire event. It was just a big mess after all was said and done.

Pam

Messages In This Thread

Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re:made from a cannon *NM*
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question
Re: Question