The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates

Before making that claim, let's produce quotes by an "academic" scholar who states that no blacks could be found in any kind of Confederate service. Unless I'm mistaken, you and Pam are making a "straw man" argument.

The only argument is whether or not armed black military commands existed within the Confederate army. Everyone agrees that blacks contributed to the Confederate cause by serving as teamsters, cooks, musicians, body servants, laborers, carpenters, nurses and almost anything else in the military except enrolled soldiers. When Lee's army surrendered at Appomattox Courthouse, there were thirty-six black men among those paroles, all in the roles listed. No one debates that, unless you can find someone who does.

If you really believe that "academics" like Art Bergeron or any other published CW author is part of a conspiracy to ignore the authentic role of black men and their service to the Confederate cause, please provide examples.

Messages In This Thread

Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Race Baiter Alert
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Re: Virginia's Black Confederates
Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
I wish we had an edit button, sorry *NM*
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Historical Process - Original Sources
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates
Re: Baton Rouge's Black Confederates