The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: What are we fighting for?
In Response To: Re: What are we fighting for? ()

Well Alan, the Union soldiers were fighting to preserve the Union, as they were ordered to do or believed to be the right thing. The individual soldier really has no say in the job they are to do once they receive orders. Some were just following orders. Some didn’t have a dog in the hunt but were already in uniform at the beginning.
The concept of any state wishing to leave the union today is difficult to fathom, but then, in that time maybe not so much. The Confederate soldier was there for a variety of reasons. Maybe they did believe their state had a right to disunion, they were drafted, they went along with friends or family, they thought it would be a quick trip but later, maybe they were trying to cause as much damage to the Union as they were seeing the Union had inflicted on Southern soil. In the last days of the Confederacy, I wonder how many hungry, tired Southern soldiers kept going with anger as their fuel?

I really do not think there is a "proof positive" for either. The Union had their reason, the Confederate States had their reason. The individual soldier in either of them was just a tool to get a job done. I’m not sure anyone really cared what they thought as an individual. That hasn’t changed since time began. Officers or Leaders give the orders and those under them follow them. If they wish to return home, they try to do a good job. Sort of applicable to the soldier today too.

McPherson, in my own, uneducated opinion, is one of the least "fair and balanced" authors or 'experts' around.

We have hashed an rehashed the States Rights issue over and over. It was probably the last thing a Confederate soldier discussed when writing home but it was very much the reason for there to be a Confederacy of States. In the time the CW was fought, many of those who were fighting had Fathers or Grandfathers who fought in the Revolutionary War or the War of 1812. It was better understood, in that time I think, than it could be now. One could possibly view the CW as a failed experiment. That attempt pretty much sealed the Union and I doubt there will ever be another attempt to bow out of it by a state. That said, the individual state does have the right to make some decisions. This is an issue today. We see it on the news daily. The more I see it in today’s light, the better I understand it 150 years ago and I also am feeling like they may have been on to something that truly wasn’t that clear to me before.. At least they tried. It just didn’t work out.

If one is in an unhappy marriage, they can get a divorce. If one is in the Union of the United States, nope, ain’t gonna happen. Irreconcilable difference wording will not fly if one is a state.

Pam

Messages In This Thread

What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Antebellum Landscape Treatments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
WHAT ? *NM*
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
ROFL!!! U got that right!!! *NM*
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Anther "I forgot"
One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Feliz Navidad, el Cumpo! *NM*
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?