The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: What are we fighting for?
In Response To: Re: What are we fighting for? ()

You said, "No, I would not accept that single Confederate Officers personal answer as the absolute only reason, because he was not any of my three grandfathers, who served as privates the entire war, who did not own slaves, but were some of the first to volunteer in 1861."

That rules out hundreds of thousands of Confederate soldiers who volunteered in 1861 who did not happen to be in your family line.

The Confederate officer in question organized a company of volunteers in the summer of 1861, led them in action under Jackson and Lee, and lost an arm fighting outside Richmond in the summer of 1864. Most of the men he led (two different Alabama regiments) were poor and never owned a slave. He answered many of the same points you raised in answer to a question by a Northern officer. The Union veteran could not understand why poor Southerners would fight so hard for so long with nothing to gain, as far as he could understand.

Since the officer in question was born in the 1830s, he does not qualify as a 20th century revisionist. That must be evident to you. Why bring that up?

I get the feeling that a thousand quotes by a thousand different Confederate veterans would be of no influence whatsoever.

Messages In This Thread

What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Antebellum Landscape Treatments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
WHAT ? *NM*
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
ROFL!!! U got that right!!! *NM*
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Anther "I forgot"
One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Feliz Navidad, el Cumpo! *NM*
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?