The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Emancipation Proclamation
In Response To: Re: Emancipation Proclamation ()

Sorry the link didn't work, Joe. The page was from Human Events' promotion of "365 Ways to Drive liberals Crazy". I've pasted it below. Stan

If a liberal ever tries to justify government intrusion using the argumentum reductio ad slaveram — that, after all, it took federal government action (the Emancipation Proclamation) to free the slaves — remind him of what he never learned in school: the Emancipation Proclamation didn't free a single slave; it had no legal standing; and it didn't even extend to areas under Union control. It was a neat, diplomatic-rhetorical dodge to prevent foreign powers from recognizing the South (as it was no longer a war over Southern independence, which was diplomatically justifiable, but presumably a war over slavery, which was not). What ended slavery was two things liberals don't often like — the United States Army and a strict construction of the Constitution, enacting change through an approved constitutional amendment — not through judicial fiat or Obamaland czars or executive orders without true legal standing.

Messages In This Thread

Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation
Re: Emancipation Proclamation