Lincoln would still have carried these four states even if his 3 opponents combined.

1860 Election

Popular Vote

State Lincoln Bell Douglas Breckinridge Total

opposing Lincoln

New York 362,646 *312,510 312,510

Indiana 139,033 5,306 115,509 12,295 133,110

Ohio 231,610 12,194 187,232 11,405 210,831

Illinois 172,161 4,913 160,215 2,404 167,532

* Fusion

Unfortunatey, I cannot ID my source for this table