There was a J.L.Reynolds, Pvt, Co E, 26th Batt'n Va Inf (Edgar's Batt'n) aka Jonathan Reynolds

There was a J.L.Reynolds, Pvt, Co C, 4th Va Cav

There was a James H. Reynols, Pvt, Co B, 26th Batt'n Va Inf (Edgar's Batt'n) aka James R. Reynolds

There was a James R. Reynolds, Pvt, Co K, 19th Va Inf and a James R. Reynolds, Pvt, Co B, 26th Batt'n Va Inf (Edgar's Batt'n)