The Alabama in the Civil War Message Board

Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Please

Ladies and Gentlemen --

We all make assumptions, and I may be guilty of making one in my responses on these message boards. I've always assumed that most people who study the Confederate war effort generally understood main points of Confederate military law. Of course, when anyone speaks of "Confederate military law" it depends on time frame, as Confederate Congressmen made regular efforts to improve on existing laws. In other words, it's a moving target.

Example: The Conscript Act of 1862 allowed a man subject to military service to opt out of the army by furnishing a substitute. On Dec 28, 1863, Congress abolished substitution, so substitution was a factor only between April 1862 and Jan 1864.

Many of you who support this board are true experts. For those of you who spend time researching Confederate military records, by your own standards, do you feel reasonably informed on the topic of Confederate military law?

It's not a test or trick question. It's simply a matter of curiousity. Responses by regular posters on other boards indicate a lack of familiarity with general dates and facts on this topic. I could be wrong about that, so I'd appreciate your responses.

Messages In This Thread

Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Please
Re: Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Plea
Re: Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Plea
Re: Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Plea
Re: Expert Opinion Required??? Your Opinions, Plea