Marian,
.
This William M. Witcher-Elizabeth Martha Gilbert family can be found in the 1860 Fannin County census, Honey Grove, p240. Two of the brothers are found in my book; one was in Bourland's Regt. Their brother Reuben E. Witcher b-1845 was possibly also in Bourland's Regt since he served in the CSA.
.
******
.
From my 200-page Name Index:
.
WITCHER, James Coleman Witcher (1839 Pittsylvania Co VA-1926 Grayson Co TX) m1-Mildred Fannie Gilbert m2-Mittie Ellen Ramsey; 1860 Fann cen p240; Grsn Co TX CSA pens #46636; 11th Cav, Co F (Co C, Bourland's Regt)

WITCHER, William Clay Witcher (1844 Pittsylvania Co VA-1931 Grayson Co TX) m-Barthena Allred (Hunt Co, TST)
.
Patti, prochette@Juno.com
.