The Arkansas in the Civil War Message Board

Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins

I'm hoping this is the same J. A. Collins who was an abolitionist before the Civil War, and particularly that I can find an elaboration of this footnote that appeared in *Progress and Poverty* by Henry George.

* One of the anitslavery agitators (Col. J. A. Collins) on a visit to England addressed a large audience in a Scotch manufacturing town, and wound up as he had been used to in the United States, by giving the ration which in the slave codes of some of the states fixed the minimum of maintenance for a slave. He quickly discovered that to many of his hearers it was an anticlimax.

It footnoted this statement:

And now that slavery has been abolished, the planters of the South find they have sustained no loss. Their ownership of the land upon which the freedmen must live gives them practically as much command of labor as before, while they are relieved of responsibility, sometimes very expensive. The Negroes as yet have the alternative of emigrating, and a great movement of that kind seems now about commencing, but as population increases and land becomes dear, the planters will get a greater proportionate share of the earnings of their laborers than they did under the system of chattel slavery, and the laborers a less share - for under the system of chattel slavery the slaves always got at least enough to keep them in good physical health, but in such countries as England there are large classes of laborers who do not get that.*

Messages In This Thread

Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins
Re: Letter to Col. S.S. Anderson from JA Collins