David,
Do you know what the letter "J." stood for in his name?
He may not be listed under H. or Hiram, but under J.

McCARLEY Hiram J. Jan. 14, 1808 Jan. 15. 1863 Nazareth Presbyterian Cemetery Spartanburg Co., SC
McCARLEY Mary Etta Dec. 26, 1852 Sept. 29. 1874 Nazareth Presbyterian Cemetery Spartanburg Co., SC
McCARLEY Minerva V. Aug. 3. 1812 Sept. 3, 1900 Nazareth Presbyterian Cemetery Spartanburg Co., SC