The Arkansas in the Civil War Message Board

Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio

Yvonne,
The Union POW records were taken from the compiled service records of "Sam Wilbern-Pvt/Sgt"---" cards filed with:
Samuel Wilbourne"-Thompson’s 4th Ark Cav- Co C, CSA

And include such cards as:

3/15/63 Enlisted Roseville
"Belonged to an Infy command when he came to this Co"

[However, there is another card in that group that states he was promoted to 3rd Sgt on 2/28/63 which is before that 3/15/63 enlistment date that is shown. That alone should make that enlistment date suspicious][Also, there is yet another card in that group that states "Enlisted 6/20/62 Roseville"]

The so called POW cards come from Union entries found in the Thompson 4th Ark Cav, Co C CSA records.

Other dates on these "are also incompatible including the date transferred to Dept of West Ms for exchange=6/17/65; and then again as 3/4/65 transfer from New Orleans to Red River Landing exchanged. The 6/17/65 date is certainly suspicious since it is after the war was over.

I believe such discrepancies [including the name variances] are:
1-Not unusual in the world of Confederate compiled service records
2-Subject to the errors easily made by those soldiers recording such events
3-There is evidence that his original muster in date is carried forward to "some" of the subsequent units with which he served
4-Other muster in dates could conceivably be connected to one of his later units and not his original unit muster in date; especially if he is trying to hide any previous enrollments to avoid charges of desertion

These compiled service records [CSR] records can certainly be beneficial and often used by researchers. Still, care should be taken in determining what may be correct and what is not.

Messages In This Thread

Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalion
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio
Re: Thompson's Regiment Co C & Clarkson's Battalio