Well golly gee I thought you KNEW the protocol for the discussion forums, after all you called yourself giving me a lesson on discussions. One more thing doesn’t matter if you agree or not, these boards belong too Jim Martin and he can run them as he pleases.

I will say this one more time for your benefit since you cannot seem to grasp any thing I have posted – I DID NOT TWIST ANYTHING PHIL SAID. Find it prove it. You are too ignorant of the posting on this board to know what you are talking about. Two if you got your information from Phil and you are the same mindset as Phil it not a wonder there is confusion. I mean someone who cannot answer a simple A, B or C question leaves a lot to be desired. Yes he was given many factual answers; I did not post one reply to him except to ask a question, are you so thick you cannot understand that? Here is my post --- http://history-sites.com/cgi-bin/bbs53x/nvcwmb/webbbs_config.pl?read=59485 I left the remaining posts to everyone else. Now you have been enlightened, try to educate yourself on the thread. When I told him he could leave I meant it was his absolutely last post http://history-sites.com/cgi-bin/bbs53x/nvcwmb/webbbs_config.pl?read=59548 . My reply to him made no insults in any way. He is leaving so long good bye. I am sure you did at least have the ability to comprehend that short post?

“George twists this simple statement into saying Phil was claming "blacks would have never fought FOR the south". It is so false and so utterly nonsensical I could hardly believe my own eyes. And simply hilarious to boot, to have such an obvious and onboxious lack of comprehension coming from someone claiming to have the ability to educate someone else on the "facts”

I believe I asked Phil if that was his position. Anyway point out the exact thread where I say such and let me read it. What exactly is “false and so utterly nonsensical, simply hilarious to boot and obvious and onboxious lack of comprehension”? Your inability to know the difference between a question and a statement? If I am wrong, surely you with all your massive knowledge can prove it to be so. What is holding you back?

Actually I don’t believe a thing you say about the German or anything else. Do you understand what I am saying? I don’t believe the truth is in a person with your level of comprehension or character. I rarely insult people it leaves a bad taste in my mouth, but since insults are the only way you know how to present your point, I think I will enjoy insulting you.

GP