The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Bona Fides
In Response To: Re: Bona Fides ()

Yep my words exactly congratulations you have learned how to copy and paste, that statement is found at http://history-sites.com/cgi-bin/bbs53x/nvcwmb/webbbs_config.pl?read=59563. Now if memory serves me correctly Phil was talking about the 54th Mass and the 54 Mass. was a black unit? If you would take the time to read Phil’s posts http://history-sites.com/cgi-bin/bbs53x/nvcwmb/webbbs_config.pl?read=59482 you will see exactly what I am referring to. Seems to me he clearly meant blacks, if not I gave him the chance to explain. As for answering a simple question Cump ask him about his line of research and his ancestors units and that is the answer he gets!!! I am almost certain this is the second time I posted this for you and you alone, is your “compression” low again?

I don’t know what Phil said about Davis, Cleburne or any others. Please point it out t to me where he made these statements. I responded to the post that I wanted to and I do believe that I have read all of Phil’s post regarding those responses. Fact is I never addressed these facts one way or the other.

Now you have had your turn at cherry picking my post and these facts still remain—

1. You have not proved that I insulted Phil in any way shape or form.
2. You have yet to prove that in any statement I made I twisted Phil’s words.
3. You haven’t proven any statement I made incorrect.
4. You have yet to deal with a certain poster who does not mind firing you way.
5. That you can answer a simple question

You are already crawfishing. Prove something -- prove me wrong. My it’s my turn, take it like a man. You haven’t proven anything except that you are a big mouth insulting blowhard that answer a simple question or even understand the threaded posts. You came here running you mouth and you are still doing the same. As I have said before you wouldn’t make a decent blackhead on some of the people I have discussions with. They may not have your education, but they don’t have to resort to insults and character assignation to make their point.

Just for your information, Blacks, Jews, Asians, Hispanics and American Indians, yes also the Irish were well represented. And also the last salve state to enter the Union was West Virginia under the Lincoln administration

GP

Messages In This Thread

Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Correction to me
Re: Correction to me
Re: Bona Fides
Re: Bona Fides
Sorry to step on your thread Cump
Re: Sorry to step on your thread Cump
Re: Sorry to step on your thread Cump
Re: Sorry to step on your thread Cump
Re: Bona Fides