The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Longstreet on Lee's Mistakes at Gettysburg

"Longstreet later offered two of three different versions of his conversations with Lee at Gettysburg. Of course Lee had gone on to his reward by then, and no one else heard or knew of these conversations."

Here is another comment concerning Lee and Longstreet by General Taylor...

"Some facts concerning this battle are established beyond dispute. In the first day's fighting a part of Lee's army defeated a part of Meade's. Intending to continue the contest on that field, a commander not smitten by idiocy would desire to concentrate and push the advantage gained by previous success and its resultant morale. But, instead of attacking at dawn, Lee's attack was postponed until afternoon of the following day, in consequence of the absence of Longstreet's corps. Federal official reports show that some of Meade's corps reached him on the second day, several hours after sunrise, and one or two late in the afternoon. It is positively asserted by many officers present, and of high rank and character, that Longstreet was nearer to Lee on the first day than Meade's reënforcing corps to their chief, and even nearer than a division of Ewell's corps, which reached the field in time to share in the first day's success. Now, it nowhere appears in Lee's report of Gettysburg that he ordered Longstreet to him or blamed him for tardiness; but his report admits errors, and quietly takes the responsibility for them on his own broad shoulders."

Messages In This Thread

Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Longstreet on Lee's Mistakes at Gettysburg
Re: Longstreet on Lee's Mistakes at Gettysburg
Re: Longstreet on Lee's Mistakes at Gettysburg
Re: Longstreet on Lee's Mistakes at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg
Re: Dick Ewell and the First Day at Gettysburg