The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Sherman's View
In Response To: Re: Kevin Did you read this? ()

"even if the Southern States be allowed to depart in peace, the first question will be revenue. Now if the South hve free trade, how can you collect revenues in eastern cities. Freight from New Orleans to St. Louis, Chicago, Louisville, Cincinnati, and even Pittsburg, would be about the same as by rail from New York, and importers at New Orleans, having no duties to pay, would undersell the East if THEY had to pay duties. Therefore, if the South make good their confederation and their plan, the Northern Confederacy must do likewise or blockade....So, look on it in any view, I see no result but war and consequent change in the form of government. Sherman

"A government resting on the caprice of the people is too unstable to last...all must obey. Government, that is, the executive, having no discretion but to execute the law must be to that extent despotic." Sherman

"We have for years been drifting towards an unadulterated democracy or demagogism. Therefore our government should become a machine, self-regulating, independent of the man." Sherman.

All from "Citizen Sherman: A Life of William Tecumseh Sherman", by Fellman, 1995.

--------------
Now with the ideas of this man, a man of the times, who now controlled a large military force, I can see a coup was committed on our system of govenment in 1861-65. I can see the South seeing these ideas coming from North, that is why the South seceded, to attempt to save themselves and their ideas of freedom and democracy.

___________________
David Upton

Messages In This Thread

North Carolinians Resist Federal Tyranny
Kevin Did you read this?
Re: Kevin Did you read this?
Re: Kevin Did you read this?
Sherman's View
Re: Sherman's View
Re: Sherman's View
Re: North Carolinians Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolinians Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny
Re: North Carolina's Resist Federal Tyranny