The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service

Your guess is correct - everyone makes mistakes.

Again citing Art Bergeron,
When the Louisiana state legislature commissioned this work, it was intended to include brief histories of all military commands. Booth's publication contains only an indiscriminate alphabetical list of companies. Booth then took all state rolls available and printed names in alphabetical order, regardless of whether or not a man belonged to a Confederate unit or the militia.

Booth's title and his inclusion of militia records is an oversight. It's like confusing a boat with a ship, or calling a rifle a "gun". Reasonable people do it every day.

Having long considered publishing a book on Alabama Confederate unit histories, I could've been guilty of exactly the same thing. The outline had always included a section on Alabama militia commands. However, my title would have suggested that militia were counted among Confederate military units. I can either change my proposed titlle or put the militia in a separate volume.

I don't wish to make the same mistake as Booth made. Thanks for calling this to my attention.

Messages In This Thread

Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First At What?
Re: Louisiana Was First At What?
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Back to School LOL *NM*
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: 1861 LA Militia Law -White Males Only
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Volunteer vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Volunteer vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Volunteer vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service (Joe Allport)
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service (Joe Allport)
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service (Joe Allport)
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Militia vs. Confederate Service
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First
Alan you're reaching for straw in
Re: Homer this is a foolish argument!
Re: Homer this is a foolish argument!
Re: Homer this is a foolish argument!
Re: The Paintball Militia
Re: The Paintball Militia
Re: The Paintball Militia
Re: The Paintball Militia
Re: The Paintball Militia
I've no idea what to use as a subject line, but ..
Re: I've no idea what to use as a subject line, bu
Re: I've no idea what to use as a subject line, bu
Re: Alan you're reaching for straw in
Re: Louisiana Was First
Re: Louisiana Was First