The proportions are with in the parameters of a Charleston made flag but does that make it so? Without documentary evidence or other similar surviving flags of the brigade of similar pattern and at the time of capture the other regiments in the brigade carried 12 star flags, it seems a bit odd that the 46th carried this particular pattern?

Gut feeling does not seem to be acceptable evidence on this board, I’m looking for the documented evidence to support yours and Greg’s claim, until then the sun has set on this thread.

Tom Martin
www.Confederate-flags.org
www.Piedmontflag.com