The Indian Territory in the Civil War Message Board

Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W

This transcription has too many errors to be useful for historical purposes. I have compared it to my copy of the microfilm. Mr. Myers, who did the transcription is a descendent of Lt Col R.C. Parks and took it on as a genealogy project. He copied from the microfilm by hand so he didn't have the original to compare to.

An error that comes to mind is that he transcribed "Star Deer-in-the-water" as "Thomas Starr [illegible]". Deer-in-the-water is a Cherokee surname. Star was in the 3rd IHG and was at home when he was killed. There is a Deer-in-the-water buried in Ft Scott Natl Cemetery who I assume was Star's father. Mr Myers also left out sections that he was not interested in from a genealogy stand point.

I would like to have a high res scan of the original as the microfilm is low quality and the photocopies of it even worse. There are many pages where the first and/or last sentence(s) is illegible on my copy. Lar Gjertveit and I have reviewed my unfinished transcription and would like to publish an annoted version some day. The biggest hold up is reviewing the original or a high resolution color scan of it.

I'm not comfortable being so critical of Mr Myers hard work but I personally would not use and could not recommend something so filled with errors.

Ken

Messages In This Thread

Ken
Re: Ken
Re: Ken
Re: Ken
Brown’s "A Life of Albert Pike"
Re: Brown’s "A Life of Albert Pike"
Re: I Found Scalesville
Re: I Found Scalesville
Re: I Found Scalesville
Re: I Found Scalesville
Re: I Found Scalesville
No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: No Scalesville in twp5N, ran 14E & 14W
Re: I Found Scalesville
Scalesville-Perryville
Re: Scalesville-Perryville
Re: Scalesville-Perryville
Brown’s "A Life of Albert Pike"