The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: NO !!!!!
In Response To: Re: NO !!!!! ()

Keith,

I used the term lightheartedly. Richard Flemings' response to Doyle Taylor asserted that the Confederacy was not a legitimate country, because it was not recognized by any foreign powers and "that's why it was called a Civil War". My response was directed at Richard's response, not to Doyle's original posting and so, we're off to the races on a completely different topic, the definition of a "Civil War".

Sometimes it's tough to stay on topic when a slight diversion from the original posting, a desire to discuss the legitimacy of the Confederate government, is diverted by a slightly off target response.

I'm still thinking about how to effectively address Jamie Robert's concerns, which I share, for threads to remain on topic with the original subject. Something like this little exchange, shows how easily we can go off course.

Jim

Messages In This Thread

Legality Question
YES *NM*
NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Re: NO !!!!!
Recognition
Re: Recognition
"Belligerent status"
Re: "Belligerent status"
Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
What would have meant ---
Re: What would have meant ---
Re: What would have meant ---
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
Re: Belligerent Parties
War Between The States.
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Good Subject Doyle! *NM*
Re: Good Subject Doyle!
Re: Good Subject Doyle!
Re: Good Subject Doyle!
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question
Re: Legality Question