Richard,
By the way, if you haven't found it, this is probably his wife, Sarah Jane Reynalds.

Find-A-Grave

Sarah J. Warren
Birth: Aug. 28, 1840
Death: Sep. 4, 1922
Burial:
Rogers Cemetery
Rogers
Benton County
Arkansas, USA
Created by: Gregg Henrikson
Record added: Jun 19, 2011
Find A Grave Memorial# 71605403

I'm convinced. :)
Jim (jrbakerjr)