The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Tory vs Yankee
In Response To: Re: Tory vs Yankee ()

Actually, Edmund Burke was the leader of the Whig party at the time of the revolution and he clearly was Pro Colonist and a great champion for the American revolutionary cause. In that frame of mind the Whigs were closer to Jackson Democrats of civil war era.

As for today, painting with a very broad brush, Tories of 1776 would likely have more in common with folks who believe in strong central government, (i.e. the King) protectionism, highly regulated tariffs/excise taxes, class/caste social systems, and oppose redistribution of income systems. I'm not sure either major modern party fits that viewpoint very well right now. So I'm not sure it behooves us to try to translate the party politics of 200 plus years ago to the current situation.

Remember, Thomas Hart Benton, Senator from Missouri had been a scion of the populist Jackson Democrats for years but when his influence began to fade he was quick to jump into the new Republican party. As for the Whigs, their positions became increasing untenable (I like to think of them using another good Missouri phrase, MugWamps, Mug on one side of the fence, Wamp on the other) and as a result they just disappeared. I think far too many people get caught in the illusion that the Whigs became the Republican Party. Not so. The Whigs were replaced as the second major party on the national stage by the Republican party and were relegated to 3rd party status along with the Constitutional Unionists by the 1864 election.

John R.

Messages In This Thread

Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Whigs
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Scots-Irish....
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
THank You Sir,,, *NM*
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
TA DA!...and for my next trick... *NM*
Re: TA DA!...and for my next trick...
Re: TA DA!...and for my next trick...
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
A thought for this day
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: WBTS
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Sorry, my Above Post was to this *NM*
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Carpe Diem--Sieze the Fish! *NM*
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Where in England do you live? *NM*
In the Muslim Section, where else? *NM*
Them Brits gonna make it warm for you. *NM*
Them Ain't Real Brits. Real Brits Love Spits *NM*
Tarleton
Re: Tarleton
From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: From King's Mountain to Sheldon Loral
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee
Re: Tory vs Yankee