The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Are You Kidding???

Frank --

I'm really disappointed! You normally post with much better substance and reason. If what you said was even remotely true, common men must have been rather uncommon in most Southern counties.

Talk of aristocracy has always been pure Northern propaganda with no foundation whatever. If any modern historian has tried to hitch his mule to an aristocracy plow and accomplish anything with it, I'm unaware of it. If you're about to point to someone's wealth and property, be reminded that there are numerous families in the North who held even greater wealth and property.

Besides, your point is mistaken. Large numbers of wealthy planters in the South supported either Bell or Douglas in the general election of 1860. Many of the wealthiest men in the South understood that secession and war imperiled their land, their slaves and their security. For the same reason many wealthy Americans supported King George during the American Revolution. From an investment/security standpoint, it just made better sense.

That dog won't hunt!

Messages In This Thread

Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
HEY.. NO POLITICS!....signed WHO me? :) *NM*
Re: HEY.. NO POLITICS!....signed WHO me? :)
LOL! *NM*
Ain't politics ----
Re: Ain't politics ----
Re: Ain't politics ----
Gaelic Sayings To Use Every Day
Re: Gaelic Sayings To Use Every Day
Re: Ain't politics ----
Re: Ain't politics ----
Yep you!!! LOL LOL LOL *NM*
Re: Ain't politics ----
Re: Ain't politics ----
Re: Ain't politics ----
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Jefferson Davis, May 1860
Re: Jefferson Davis, May 1860
Re: Jefferson Davis, May 1860
Speaking of Jefferson Davis 6 Nov 1861
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act *NM*
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: The Arsenal at Little Rock
Re: Arkansas Slavery
Re: Arkansas Slavery
Re: The Kansas-Nebraska Act
Re: Slavery in Arkansas
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Harper's Ferry and Religous Fundamentalists
Re: Harper's Ferry and Religous Fundamentalists
Re: Harper's Ferry and Religous Fundamentalists
Re: Harper's Ferry and Religous Fundamentalists
Re: Harper's Ferry and Religous Fundamentalists
Certified Kansas Nut *NM*
Re: Certified Kansas Nut
Re: Certified Kansas Nut
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Are You Kidding???
Re: Are You Kidding???
Re: Are You Kidding???
Re: Are You Kidding???
Re: Are You Kidding???
Re: Are You Kidding???
uhh oh
Re: uhh oh
Re: uhh oh
Re: uhh oh
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Rewards for Arrest of Deserters
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Background on Alabama Home Guards
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Cold-blooded Murder is a "Nice Story"
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Property Ownership Question
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Anderson planned the first military action.
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Anderson's Authority
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Postwar Southern Economy
Re: Postwar Southern Economy
Re: The American System
Re: The American System
Re: You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Re: Frank, You Gotta Be Kidding, Part II
Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantations
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: Pearl River Navigation
Re: Pearl River Navigation
Re: Pearl River Navigation
Re: Pearl River Navigation
Re: Pearl River Navigation
Re: Pearl River Navigation--a carrot
Re: Pearl River Navigation--a carrot
Re: Pearl River Navigation--a carrot
Re: Pearl River Navigation--a carrot
Re: Simpson County merchants
Re: Simpson County merchants
Re: Simpson County merchants
Re: Limitations of Slave Farming and Slave Plantat
Re: No Argument Here --- *NM*
Re: The American System
Re: The American System
Re: Car Ownership Question correction
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Facing the Slavery Issue Directly
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again
Re: Al Sharpton upset...again