The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Because You are Here
In Response To: Because You are Here ()

Or as in the Movie "Gettysburg" where Chamberlain is questioning a confederate prisoner about why they were fighting and the reply was that they 'were fightin' fur their rats'.

There is a basic primal instinct somewhere hidden here that even before there was any fighting, as in 1860 and before, that men felt the need to defend something. And that basic instinct drove them to take the actions that they did. We are taught that this something was the institution of slavery, but I don't believe that, because men do not fight with such dedication to something they do not fully believe in and are not wholely commited to.

For Example our army today is a volunteer army. Do our soldiers, in our army today, fight because they are told to? Or do they fight because they live in the United States? Do they fight to protect their families? Or do they fight because they believe in something other than these United States, some idealogy?

The truth is that they will fight for all of those reasons, but which is the strongest incentive?

How many of them do you think fight for the United States Government and the President? Or for Bill Gates to own a Cadillac? No, you don't volunteer and put your life on the battle line for such silly things. You sell your life for dearer things than that.

I can understand the Northern Soldier fighting to "Preserve the Union" to preserve the Status Quo, like England in 1776. But, I can also understand the Southern soldier, and my Grandfathers, fighting for "Independence" like the 13 colonies.

Messages In This Thread

What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Antebellum Landscape Treatments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
WHAT ? *NM*
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: WHAT ?
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
Re: Rammer Jammer Yellow Hammer
ROFL!!! U got that right!!! *NM*
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: Emory Upton
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: Pearl Harbor Enlistments
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: Blame the French
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Re: On the Run from the Law
Anther "I forgot"
One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Re: One soldier's reason
Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: Because You are Here
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: Detailed Data on Southern Cuture
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: North and South at West Point
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: Let Us Now Praise Famous Men
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: Literacy North and South
Feliz Navidad, el Cumpo! *NM*
Re: Literacy North and South
Re: What are we fighting for?
Re: What are we fighting for?