The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended

[How would history judge a president who failed to take any and all measures to preserve his country? Do we expect a president to be a moral icon, or do we expect him to do whatever it takes to defend the nation? Is a president, who adheres strictly to the law and the Constitution, but loses the war and allows the country to be destroyed, a patriot or a traitor?]

Questions , for the mind to ponder,,,,

A question to debate a question, how would we judge a President who did everything to further his cause no matter how legal or illegal. When he did everything to cause his Country to be imperiled in the first place?

I expect a President to do what he swore to do at his inauguration, Preserve and Protect the Consitution. Trampling the Rights of citizens wasn't in his oath, or yours as a Naval Officer or mine as a State Peace Officer. He has a military to defend the country and Police Officers to enforce the laws. We can't let Maryland happen again.

I can't answer that last one Bryan unless you figure he is a man of his word. I would say he was a righteous man who did what he could without taking away the rights of the citizenry. But this is a loaded question, not by you, but can only be answered hypothetically. I don't think anyone can honestly say what he would think in that case.

Messages In This Thread

Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
War Suspended...Ended
Re: War Suspended...Ended
The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
He made same statement in WBTS *NM*
Must have liked the phrase,,,,,,, *NM*
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
The Constitution, Secession & Executive Authority
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
I just omit "indivisible" *NM*
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
How we read!
Re: How we read!
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Here is something...Federalist No. 43
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 22
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 16
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 8
A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended