The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author

Doyle, first, I am not even close to being an expert on either the US Constitution or the Declaration of Independence. With that having been said, let me react to your post.

I believe the US Constitution, along with the Amendments and related case law (including derivative Public Laws) is the sole and only body of law governing what is and is not legal in the United States

I believe the Declaration of Independence is not law in this country. It is two things - a statement of the underlying causes and derivative rights related to America's secession from Great Britain and, as you say, a "foundation document," that much of the Constitution was predicated upon. That is all it is. Again, it is not law.

In short, provisions of the Declaration of Independence that did not find their way into the US Constitution do not, in my opinion, carry the weight of law.

Can you point to any historical document, just one, that even suggests, if not declares that a "Right of Secession" was at any time during the drafting of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights understood by any one involved in any way with the creation of either document to be an Amendment IX "other" non-enumerated right?

This, along with the philosophical conundrum I identified above, has been the source of much confliction in my mind for many years.

Perhaps you can clear it up for me, Doyle?

Messages In This Thread

Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
War Suspended...Ended
Re: War Suspended...Ended
The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: The Cotton Bowl
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
He made same statement in WBTS *NM*
Must have liked the phrase,,,,,,, *NM*
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
The Constitution, Secession & Executive Authority
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
I just omit "indivisible" *NM*
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
Re: You Picked Some Good Ones
How we read!
Re: How we read!
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Re: The Constitution, Secession & Executive Author
Here is something...Federalist No. 43
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 22
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 16
Re: Here is something...Federalist No. 8
A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: A Little Recognition for David Upton
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended
Re: Writ of Habeus Corpus Suspended