The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Answering Craig
In Response To: Re: Answering Craig ()

1. Really? I'll have to check that out. I thought they banned the import of slaves from all countries but one.

2. Ah but remember the letter Lincoln forged and sent to the Confederates? I believe it stated something similar to " the president intends to re-supply and re-enforce---"

I also believe that Lincoln refused to meet with peace delegates.

3. The law against secession was only assumed also.

4. Well if the restrictions were placed on the states, secession was not one of them, however the rights over the regulation of slaves was given to them. Looking at the northern states I see the black codes, which seem to be perfectly legal and were for the good of the states, so that right surely must have still been intact. In fact wasn't one of the reasons that the Southern states started seceding was because the new territories were not allowed to choose whether they would be free or slave?

“My take on secession is an interpretation. No one can factually say that secession was absolutely legal or absolutely illegal before the Civil War.”
Since your take is simply your interpretation wouldn’t you say it is possible that you are wrong?

Messages In This Thread

Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Who was convicted of treason?? *NM*
Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Absolutely no case...repeat from Dec. 17th, 2006
Re: Absolutely no case...repeat from Dec. 17th, 20
Re: Changing the question?
Ex Post Facto
Re: Ex Post Facto
Re: Ex Post Facto
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Answering Craig
Try this link
Re: Try this link
Thanks George. *NM*