The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Answering Craig
In Response To: Re: Answering Craig ()

Jamie,

"I have to ask though, did the north seek grievance in legal proceedings or did the Lincoln government go to war? I've always felt both sides share the blame for starting a war that should have been avoided."

I agree that no single person, state or entity could take all responsibility for the war. Yet, it might be possible to identify things that were more responsible.

In a class years ago, my professor asked where most responsibility for the war lay. Ultimately, I look more towards the Deep South, for despite all of their grievances (legitimate or not), the single most important step leading to war was secession. The sectional conflict had lasted for decades, but had largely remained a political battle (except for Kansas territory). The minute those states passed ordinances of secession, the internal political battle turned into a monumental Constitutional crisis. Without secession there would not have been a war---plain and simple.

Oh, and thank you for the warm welcome to the board. I look forward to more discussions...at least as my hectic schedule will allow.

Messages In This Thread

Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Fort Sumter and amphibious operations
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Re: Answering Craig
Who was convicted of treason?? *NM*
Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Absolutely no case...repeat from Dec. 17th, 2006
Re: Absolutely no case...repeat from Dec. 17th, 20
Re: Changing the question?
Ex Post Facto
Re: Ex Post Facto
Re: Ex Post Facto
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Changing the question?
Re: Answering Craig
Try this link
Re: Try this link
Thanks George. *NM*