The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie

This is why giving payments as restitution of slavery is impractical. Payment is not restitution anymore than granting citizenship, because it does not restore persons to their original condition. Even so the granting of citizenship is not without a value. It fact of matter Citizenship in this country is very valueable, and something that other peoples of the world would pay a great price to obtain.

The actual act of taking and placing of persons into "slavery" did not occur in this country. This was not the "scene of the Crime". This country has never conquered a people and placed them into slavery. Any slave which came to this country was in that condition prior to their arrival in this country, and for that matter were in that condition before they ever boarded a ship which brought them here. Even the indentured servants which came to this country as payment for crimes or placed themselves into that situation as payment for their passage to this country, such as my GGGG-grandparents.

Was the Southern states even a cause for the market in a slave trade? NO!

The slave trade existed in the world market place, and was a common place practise, far longer that the American Colonies ever existed and certainly much longer than the United States has existed. And even if that were the case, the Northern Rum trade for sugar, from the Bahamas particularly in Massachusetts and other New England colonies and later, states, was more of a driving cause in the expansion of the North American slave trade institution than was that of the Southern argiculture.

Messages In This Thread

Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Thanks for the info Dennis *NM*
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Contract Colonies..Coal Mines
Re: Colonization Efforts During the Civil War
Re: Colonization Efforts During the Civil War
Re: Colonization Efforts During the Civil War
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Discovering history...
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: Same As Most Other Americans
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
this is the books title
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie
Re: Lincoln: the Man, not the Movie