The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: To all you peoples!
In Response To: Re: To all you peoples! ()

"If you dismiss this book as a source, are we supposed to dismiss all books a published after the war?"

I didn't, I simply wondered how his postwar perspective compares with his prewar position. As mentioned above, it is called critical reading.

"That being the case Lincoln nor any Northern state said before the start of the war they would fight to free the slaves"

Never said they did. That is your standard response to the assertion that the southern states seceded to protect slavery.

"no Southern state said they fight to keep the slaves"

No, the southern states just said they would secede to keep the slaves. It was individual politicians, newspapers, snd various fire-eaters that said they would fight to keep the slaves.

Messages In This Thread

Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: What Caused the Civil War
Re: What Caused the Civil War
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Forgot to mention---
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
I knew it!!!
Re: I knew it!!!
Re: I knew it!!!
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
LOL *NM*
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: Flag History
Re: Flag History
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
I do! and yes, you are. LOL *NM*
Re: I do! and yes, you are. LOL
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Welcome *NM*
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature