The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
In Response To: Re: To all you peoples! ()

Thanks for making an attempt to create a reasonable analogy. If you've not already read the book, you may enjoy What Caused The Civil War by Edward L. Ayers (2005). Here's a review --
http://www.enotes.com/what-caused-civil-war-salem/what-caused-civil-war

In one chapter Ayers explores north-south conflict in other countries. Evidently most countries across the globe have experienced north-south or east-west conflicts, sometimes both. Ayers applies some interesting twists to arguments that have been around since Appomattox. If you decide to pick it up, please let me know what you think.

We part ways on the issue of no one having a right to break up the country. Washington, Jefferson, Adams et al certainly believed in the right of rebellion to establish an independent country. There's a Biblical example of secession in the Old Testament, after which The Almighty intervened to end a potential civil war. Even Abraham Lincoln acknowleged the right of secession, but only if Congress formally approved actions submitted by the individual states. Wouldn't you have loved to have heard those debates?

Messages In This Thread

Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: What Caused the Civil War
Re: What Caused the Civil War
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Forgot to mention---
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
I knew it!!!
Re: I knew it!!!
Re: I knew it!!!
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: I knew that----
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
Re: Edward L. Ayers, "What Caused the Civil War"
LOL *NM*
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: To all you peoples!
Re: Flag History
Re: Flag History
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: P.S.-- To no one person.
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
I do! and yes, you are. LOL *NM*
Re: I do! and yes, you are. LOL
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Welcome *NM*
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature
Re: Pressing Issues for the Alabama Legislature