The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War

This is a well written essay from the Richmond Times-Dispatch two days ago.

“Slavery began in Virginia in 1619, not 1861. It is an injustice to pile the sins of 250 years of the "peculiar institution" on the brave men who went forth against the invaders between 1861 and 1865. As we commemorate their heroism and sacrifice, we do not forget the peculiar institution, but at the same time we must not let political correctness corrupt our judgment and our historical understanding. As noted historian James McPherson wrote in What They Fought For, 1861-1865, the vast majority of Southern soldiers believed they were fighting to defend their state, their homes, and their families -- not slavery.”

http://www2.timesdispatch.com/news/2010/aug/29/ed-hines29-ar-476774/?referer=http://mail.aol.com/32447-111/aol-1/en-us/mail/DisplayMessage.aspx?ws_popup=true&shorturl=http://timesdispatch.com/ar/476774/

Messages In This Thread

No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: Slavery in the Northern States
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: Slavery in the Northern States
Re: Slavery in the Northern States
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Comments closed
Re: Comments closed
Re: Comments closed
Re: Comments closed
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War
Re: What Did 'States Rights' Mean in 1860?
Re: What Did 'States Rights' Mean in 1860?
Re: What Did 'States Rights' Mean in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Like in 1960?
Re: What Were People Like in 1960?
Re: What Were People Like in 1960?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: What Were People Discussing in 1860?
Re: No, Slavery did not Cause the Civil War