The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: Its all about me....
In Response To: Its all about me.... ()

"Thats because you have twisted and warped my words so much you started reading your words thinking they were mine. The only words that I've seen changed are the ones you said I said which I didn't. My words you wrote arn't mine there yours which you use against me saying there mine. See?"

Wait, you think I made up statements I attributed to you? Really?

I'll go ahead and provide the phrases I quoted you, with their respective links:

Originally, I wrote: "As I said before, in 1860 only a small population of radical abolitionists supported a sweeping national ban against slavery. Following events so dramatically changed American perceptions that by 1865---in only 5 years---the federal government (and most northerners) was pushing an emancipation amendment. This transition was not "inexcusably" slow, but remarkably swift."

You replied: "After further thought I totally disagree with this statement. Our subject is the Congress of the United States in 61-65, not the general public. The overwhelming majority in Congress came from slave-free states or states that had abolished the institution. Men who knew the ways of the world, and that in Europe the abolishment of slavery was popular. Many of these men were put into office by abolitionist groups whose goal was to have a nation free of slavery. Your thesis is an assumption is these Congresses would not have ever been exposed to the idea on a nation wide ban on salvery, therefore they never would have thought of proposing it, until sometime around 1865." http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48571

(Perhaps you can explain to me now why you disagree with my above statement when it argues the same thing now claim---most in Congress did not want to end slavery at the beginning of the war.)

In your next post, you say: "It only takes one to bring it to the floor for debate. The point being they knew that the question must be asked. Asking the question was simple. It was not done for what ever reason."
http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48632

Maybe you can explain how this meshes with your next post, which claimed: "The problem with this many people in POWER wanted immediate emancipation, forcing Lincoln to address their needs. Radicals shelved their emancipation movement, just before the election, to help get their man in the White House. Once he got in, they came back out." http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48681

So, on one hand you say no one brought up national emancipation, even though it only needed one person to address it on the floor of Congress. Then, in your very next message, you claim that many people in power were radical abolitionists who agitated strongly for their interests. So, which is it? Were people pushing for immedicate emancipation or not?

On the issue of modern judgments, you said: "So why can't Southerners be ready to condemn their ancestors for owning or selling slaves even if it were legal?" http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48752

I then asked you to clarify on the matter: "Do you believe that justifies modern-day Americans condemning 19th century Americans who did not believe slavery was immoral?"

You denied your previous statement completely: "Excuse me? Don't recall saying that." http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48828

Overall, why would I make up things you said when there is a very clear record of what you wrote available to us all? Do you not remember writing these conflicting sentences?

Finally, you said: "If they really wanted to end slavery in 1861-62 they could have, they didn't want to."

I replied: "Yes, if a majority in Congress wanted that to happen, they could have. I have never disputed that."

Your reply: "YAHOO! Strike three, inning over, thats the game. SEEEEEYaaaaaaaaaaaa in the funny papers!"

What in the world is that about? I assume you think you got me to admit something I had denied, and therefore I "struck out"? If that is what you believe, then you better check my post from last Wednesday to you, in which I said:

"Congress, as a body, always had the authority to pass an amendment abolishing slavery. What is important is when people in Congress were willing to use that authority for that end." http://history-sites.com/mb/cw/nvcwmb/index.cgi?read=48530

Perhaps I should congratulate you for finally catching up with me. LOL

Messages In This Thread

Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
Re: Confiscation Act approved
I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
One final note
Re: Black Confederates
Re: Black Confederates
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Cannon fodder
Re: Cannon fodder
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
One clarification
Re: I'm talking about reality
Re: I'm talking about reality
He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: See the war wasn't about slavery...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Its all about me....
Re: Its all about me....
Re: Its all about me....
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Re: He had the power...
Point -Set - Match, Paul *NM*