The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum

Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
In Response To: Re: Arming the Slaves (PS) ()

George my only point all along has been this: no matter what the leadership said was the motivation for why they were fighting at the start, the choices they made in the course of the war (actions speak louder than words) clearly show their priorities. After continous pleas from Generals in the field, some of them the best generals the south had, that the path to independence lay in emancipating and arming huge numbers of slaves, they refused to take that enancipate and arm route. In the end the refusal cost them the independence they claim was their only goal.

That it took Lincoln a long time to emancipate is of little concern strategically. His stated goal was not emancipation but reunification. He chose whatever policy he thought would work best toward that goal. Large numbers of Union soldiers hated the EP and large numbers strongly opposed the idea of black troops. In very little time however, they had a dramatic and sudden, and almost universal change of heart and wanted more black soldiers sharing combat responsibility. They quickly realized that the more blacks in the fight lifted their burden and their risk. The white Union troops realized more armed blacks in combat improved their chances of seeing home again.

As this became more obvious to everyone the practice became more popular to troops and family alike and was increased. Lincoln adjusted his policies as they furthered his main goal. This does not seem to be the case with the CSA leadership for the most part. Lincoln adapted they did not. I personally think his administrations' policy of stopping POW exchanges was brutal and inhumane to loyal Union men suffering in captivity.. but it was effective policy as it denied the South a return of combat soldiers.

It was a horrific sacrifce, and a very very hard choice to make. The CSA had a hard choice to make about arming and freeing slaves and even in the end could not bear to do so.

But in the South, they would forcibly draft almost any and every available and able white male of draftable age, and later included boys and old men, and a family might give every single one of their white sons to the cause, while the black half of the population mostly stayed put. Safely out of harms way.

Even when arming slaves became policy in February 65, only 20% of a regions slaves could be taken. Priorities. We will risk every last one of your white sons, who are expendible, but only a fifth of your black slaves, who we cannot risk losing.

This doesn't even begin to consider the additional cost of the white manpower kept away from active combat because they were needed in order to man local patrols to control potential runaways slaves or uprisings, and keep a check on the slave population, and keep them working productively. Maintaining slavery was costly in white manpower to a government that clearly needed more men, yet was unwilling to adapt.

If you were a father and had to send one member of your household to face grave danger, maybe never to see him again in this life, which would you chose to throw into harm's way... your only son or one of your field hands? In a sinking lifeboat which would you toss first, to lighten the load, and maybe save your life, the anchor, or your trunk of valuables? Priorities are revealing.

Messages In This Thread

Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: I Give Up, You Win
Re: I Give Up, You Win
Re: I Give Up, You Win
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
Re: Jim, Alan, JAKEo
CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: CSA black POWs Vs Union black POWs
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Fornication of the truth---lol *NM*
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
ADMIN! Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
PS Alan
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Louisiana Native Guard
Re: Louisiana Native Guard
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Military Expedience not Abolitionist Morality
Re: Arming the Slaves
Defying the politicians
Re: Defying the politicians
Re: Defying the politicians
Re: Defying the politicians
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Slavery - Yes and No
Re: Slavery - Yes and No
Re: Slavery - Yes and No
Re: Slavery - Yes and No
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
(PS) George
Re: Arming the Slaves (PS)
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves
Re: Arming the Slaves