The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Southerners as an Ethnic Minority

Chase --

Thanks for raising the point I meant to save for another time. Since we're talking about mass politics, I hope none of of seriously believe that a small group of men have a master plan to manipulate the outcome of elections.

Since the middle of the 19th century, Southerners have been regarded as an undesirable ethnic minority. James Webb in Born Fighting: How the Scots-Irish Shaped America believes this prejudice goes back at least another century.

Since women couldn't vote during much of the period under consideration, it's not reasonable to consider the lack of female candidates. As for the other two minorities, a news survey taken in Detroit MI in 1960 asked readers to identify the least desirable ethnic groups. White Southerners (AKA "rednecks") easily won over the other groups you identified.

That kind of prejudice should explain why Southerners weren't considered viable candidates for national office during this era.

Webb presents a great deal of support for this point. It's really not necessary, since almost anyone who grew up in the United States is fully ware of the cultural stereotypes. Note also that we can use the term 'red neck' in a post, but not other ethnic slurs.

Messages In This Thread

Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Exactly. *NM*
Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
LOL *NM*
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
ADMIN! Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Thanks, George *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
"when anyone looks for predjudice"
LOL! *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Let it go Chase *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
"Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: THANKS JIM *NM*
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Thanks for the figures... *NM*
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
StLouis Irish
Re: StLouis Irish
"History books writtem by winners"
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Thank You Sir! *NM*
Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Presidential Elections, 1868-1960
Hoover was from Iowa. *NM*
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas *NM*
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas
Re: Hoover was from Iowa -- Really?
Yes really!
Re: Yes really!
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...