The Civil War News & Views Open Discussion Forum - Archive

Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
In Response To: Re: James Webb - Born Fighting ()

Here's what Webb wrote in Born Fighting: How the Scots-Irish Shaped America that got my attention --

The Civil War, we are taught, was about slavery, an institution that at the same time both nurtured and corrupted the South. The Union, we are now told, was on the side of God and the angels, its soldiers dedicated to eliminating this dark stain on the human spirit. The Union Army, we are reminded again and again even in these modern times, marched to a "Battle Hymn", one that still inundates political and patriotic ceremonies.

As He died to make men holy,
Let us die to make men free,
His truth is marching on...

By implication, the soldiers of the Confederacy were with the forces of darkness and evil, fighting to preserve a system that denigrated the human spirit and made mules out of men.

[page 220]

The greatest disservice on this count has been the attempt by these revisionist politicians and academics to defame the entire Confederate Army in a move that can only be termed the Nazification of the Confederacy. Often cloaked in the argument over public display of the Confederate battle flag, the syllogism goes something like this:

Slavery was evil.
The soldiers of the Confederacy fought for a system that wished to preserve it.
Therefore they were evil as well, and any attempt to honor their service is a veiled effort to glorify the cause of slavery....

[This effort] dishonors hundreds of thousands of men who can defend themselves only through the voices of their descendants.

[pages 207-08]

I don't know about anyone else, but folks, Webb's last sentence hit me right square between the eyes.

Messages In This Thread

Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Exactly. *NM*
Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
Re: Is everybody an Ethnic Minority
LOL *NM*
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
ADMIN! Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Thanks, George *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
"when anyone looks for predjudice"
LOL! *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Let it go Chase *NM*
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Getting Us Back on Track
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
Re: Using the "T" Word
"Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: THANKS JIM *NM*
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Thanks for the figures... *NM*
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
Re: "Whos upset by failed rev of 1848"
StLouis Irish
Re: StLouis Irish
"History books writtem by winners"
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Re: Everyone isn't an Ethnic Minority
Thank You Sir! *NM*
Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Yo, James!
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: James Webb - Born Fighting
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Southerners as an Ethnic Minority
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Presidential Elections, 1868-1960
Hoover was from Iowa. *NM*
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas *NM*
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas
Re: And Dwight David Eisenhower was from Texas
Re: Hoover was from Iowa -- Really?
Yes really!
Re: Yes really!
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...
Re: Let's Try This One Again...